Saturday, November 21, 2026 Verified Clinical Portal
Anxiety Fact-Checked Health Content

Teaching: Does It Benefit Us to Be Intellectually Humble?

7h ago 9 min read
Teaching: Does It Benefit Us to Be Intellectually Humble?

Observer

Teaching: Does It Benefit Us to Be Intellectually Humble?

Use this lesson plan to teach students about intellectual humility, when it’s effective, and its potential downsides.

Aimed at integrating cutting-edge psychological science into the classroom, columns about teaching Current Directions in Psychological Science offer advice and how-to guidance about teaching a particular area of research or topic in psychological science that has been the focus of an article in the APS journal Current Directions in Psychological Science.


Editor’s Note

A note from TCD Editor Beth Morling: “This will be Cindi May’s last contribution to the Teaching with Current Directions column, as she is making time for other ventures. Cindi has been writing with us since 2015, and we are grateful for the many ways she has helped teachers of psychology keep their teaching current with the latest psychological science.

When I asked Cindi to think back on her past columns, she named two favorites. One is “Don’t go shoe shopping when you’re hungry: How cognitive mindsets carry over from one task to another” (written with Gil Einstein in 2018) and “One face, many places: The development of different cortical regions responsible for face processing” (written with Michael Scullin in 2025).

Thank you so much, Cindi—we wish you the best in your next adventure!”

A note from Cindi May: “Over the past decade, I have found tremendous satisfaction in translating important scientific findings into accessible demonstrations and engaging discussions that bring psychological science to life in the classroom. Being part of this writing team has been equally rewarding, and the experience has taught me a great deal—both about the science itself, and about the craft of communicating it in ways that inspire curiosity and deepen student learning. Special thanks to Dave Myers, who patiently helped me develop as a writer, and to Gilles Einstein and Michael Scullin, both of whom made the writing process fun.”

Koetke, J., & Schumann, K. (2026). Intellectual humility in the eyes of others: Implications for social perception and trust. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 35(5), 266–273.

Imagine you are trying to convince your partner to install solar panels on your home. The investment will be costly, and you know your partner is reluctant to spend money this way. Nevertheless, they acknowledge that their knowledge of solar energy is limited, listen carefully as you explain your reasoning, and ask questions that reflect a genuine desire to learn more before making a decision. In this interaction, you are likely to perceive your partner as intellectually humble: aware of their own intellectual limitations, open to considering other perspectives, and motivated to acquire new knowledge.

Being perceived as intellectually humble carries significant advantages. We tend to feel warmer toward people who demonstrate intellectual humility and view them as more competent and trustworthy (Koetke & Schumann, 2025a; Rodriguez et al., 2019). We are also more inclined to spend time with them, forgive their transgressions, follow their recommendations, and even select them as leaders (Hodge et al., 2020; Knochelmann & Cohrs, 2024; Koetke & Schumann, 2025b). Indeed, we often want—and even expect—professionals in our communities, including teachers, doctors, law enforcement officers, and journalists, to demonstrate intellectual humility (Koetke & Schumann, 2025c).

Yet recent research by Jonah Koetke and Karina Schumann suggests that intellectual humility can also backfire. Its benefits are not universal; they depend on the context, the audience, and the individual demonstrating it. For example, expressing intellectual humility about issues widely regarded as factual (e.g., that smoking is harmful to one’s health) or morally nonnegotiable (e.g., that torturing innocent people is wrong) can undermine perceptions of one’s competence and reasoning ability (Koetke & Schumann, 2025a). Moreover, what people regard as factual or nonnegotiable is not always universal. A politician may alienate their base or appear indecisive by expressing substantial intellectual humility when discussing divisive issues such as gun control or immigration. Intellectual humility may also carry greater risks for certain individuals. Women and members of marginalized groups may be particularly disadvantaged when audiences already harbor doubts about their knowledge or competence. Thus, being perceived as intellectually humble can offer substantial interpersonal and professional advantages, but those benefits are contingent on the goals of the interaction and the broader cultural and interpersonal context.

Although researchers have begun to identify when intellectual humility is helpful versus harmful, this remains an emerging field. We do not yet fully understand which specific behaviors and language convey intellectual humility. We don’t know whether these signals vary across individuals, situations, and cultures. Nor do we know whether perceptions of intellectual humility are influenced by the personality and dispositions of the observer or the target. Finally, it remains unclear whether these perceptions are specific to a particular moment (i.e., state humility) or reflect enduring judgments (i.e., trait humility).

Student Activity

To introduce students to intellectual humility and engage them in this evolving area of research, begin by dividing the class into pairs or small groups. Ask students to name and describe someone they consider to be intellectually humble. Initially, they may offer broad descriptions such as “someone who recognizes the limits of their own knowledge” or “someone who does not assume their knowledge or beliefs are superior to those of others.”

Next, challenge students to think like psychological scientists by operationalizing intellectual humility. What specific, observable, and measurable behaviors could we study? Encourage students to develop a list and then consider how they might measure these behaviors in a psychological study. What would they observe, measure, or manipulate? How would they distinguish genuine intellectual humility from simply appearing agreeable, open-minded, or uncertain?

Once students have identified potential indicators, ask them to consider the circumstances in which being perceived as intellectually humble might be particularly beneficial or detrimental. One important consideration is the timeframe. Someone who carefully considers viewpoints from multiple sources might be perceived as indecisive in the short term. In some situations, such as a pandemic outbreak or natural disaster, delays in decision making could have serious consequences. In other circumstances, such as an economic crisis, taking time to consider alternative perspectives may lead to better decisions and more favorable long-term outcomes.

Finally, encourage students to consider whether the advantages of being perceived as intellectually humble are distributed equally across individuals. Might intellectual humility enhance the image of some people while undermining that of others? For example, because intellectual humility is often associated with warmth, it may soften perceptions of an otherwise powerful or dominant leader. The same behaviors, however, might undermine perceptions of individuals with less authority or influence, particularly those who are not traditionally perceived as confident or self-assured. Ask students to consider how characteristics of both the speaker and the audience might shape these judgments.

Intellectual humility reminds us that even seemingly desirable personal qualities do not operate in a vacuum. The same behaviors that foster trust, cooperation, and better decision making in one context may signal weakness, indecisiveness, or incompetence in another. Understanding when and why these perceptions emerge requires us to look beyond the individual and consider the interaction between behavior, the situation, and the people interpreting it.

For students, intellectual humility offers a broader lesson in psychological thinking: The value of a particular behavior often depends not simply on what someone does, but on when, why, and in whose eyes they do it.

Researcher Teacher-Feature

Almost all university researchers are teachers, too. We invite the scientists featured in our column to answer questions about their own teaching. We hope that this feature inspires you and sparks your curiosity!

Dr. Koetke, what’s your institution, and which courses do you teach the most? How large are your classes?

I am currently a postdoctoral researcher at The Ohio State University. I am not currently teaching in my postdoc, but during my graduate training, I taught nine courses as the instructor of record at the University of Pittsburgh. I taught Intro to Social Psychology (larger classes with around 90 students) and Conflict Resolution (smaller classes with around 30 students).

What comes to mind when you reflect on the intersection of teaching and research?

I think about how I try to model intellectual humility when I teach. Our research shows that people want scientists and teachers to be intellectually humble, and that this plays an important role in building trust. I therefore try to acknowledge when I am not sure of an answer or when I am wrong. I also encourage students to do the same. Because intellectual humility is such an important part of the scientific process, I think that this is an important practice when teaching students who are training to become scientists themselves.

Feedback on this article? Email [email protected] or login to comment.

Additional References

Hodge, A. S., Mosher, D. K., Davis, C. W., Captari, L. E., Hook, J. N., Davis, D. E., & Van Tongeren, D. R. (2020). Political humility and forgiveness of a political hurt or offense. Journal of Psychology and Theology, 48(2), 142–153.

Knöchelmann, L., & Cohrs, J. C. (2024). Effects of intellectual humility in the context of affective polarization: Approaching and avoiding others in controversial political discussions. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 129(1), 91–117.

Koetke, J., & Schumann, K. (2025a). Are there consequences of expressing intellectual humility toward claims perceived as established or moral truths? Implications for judgments of expresser’s competence and warmth. Social Psychological and Personality Science, 17(2), 181–193.

Koetke, J., & Schumann, K. (2025b). Do we really think our politicians should be intellectually humble? Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 118, Article 104729.

Koetke, J., & Schumann, K. (2025c). Lay preferences for and perceptions of intellectual humility across societal roles. Social Cognition, 43(2), 97–113.

Rodriguez, D., Hook, J. N., Farrell, J. E., Mosher, D. K., Zhang, H., Van Tongeren, D. R., Davis, D. E., Aten, J. D., & Hill, P. C. (2019). Religious intellectual humility, attitude change, and closeness following religious disagreement. The Journal of Positive Psychology, 14(2), 133–140.

More news

Observer

You Don’t Have to Decide Between Basic and Applied Science

Observer

Who Has the Power to Change?

Observer

Teaching the Effects of Facial Processing in Babies

Leave a comment Cancel reply

APS regularly opens certain online articles for discussion on our website. You must be a signed-in APS member to post comments. By posting a comment, you agree to our Community Guidelines and the display of your profile information, including your name and affiliation. Any opinions, findings, conclusions, or recommendations present in article comments are those of the writers and do not necessarily reflect the views of APS or the article’s author.

Sign in with your APS account to comment.

Sign in Become a member


Disclaimer: This story is auto-aggregated by a computer program and has not been created or edited by HealthlyDays – Health, Wellness, Fitness & Healthy Living.
Publisher: Source link

Healthly Days Editorial Team

This article was curated and reviewed for clarity and reader accessibility by the Healthly Days healthcare content system.